Click to download:
Wildlife in Rio project Project for this unit
Example from last year https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y2GHBIrPcJs&feature=youtu.be
LESSON ONE: Evidence for Evolution 5.1
Fundamental questions: What does ‘evolution’ actually mean? How does the idea of evolution differ from other ideas about species? What evidence can we see for evolution?
- Fossil: preserved remains, or an impression, of a living organism found in rock
- Homologous features: Structural similarities that underlie features in two different organisms eg. forelimbs of vertebrates.
- Analogous features: Functional similarities combined with quite different underlying structural designs eg. an insects wings, and a birds wings.
- Geological time-period. A period of geological time associated with the formation of certain rock layers eg. Mesozoic.
introductory activity: Skull exploration:
- Try to identify the skulls
- Look for ones that are similar to each other
- Suggest reasons why you think they might be similar to each other
- Be prepared to feedback to the class
Evolution means ‘change’, and encapsulates the idea that the characteristics of species are not fixed in time; but that they have changed, and may continue to change.
Click on the link below to investigate some evidence for evolution
Evidence for Evolution:
the preserved remains of organisms found in the rocks of the Earth suggest that organisms have changed over time (eg. Snakes evolving from reptiles)
similar physiology in organisms which may suggest a common ancestor
Distribution in space and time
The chronology of different animals fits the ages of the rocks (different kinds of organisms existed in different times)
We have actually observed some modern examples of how organisms can change eg. wolves -) domestic dogs, antibiotic resistance in bacteria.
5.2 Lesson one: NATURAL SELECTION
Essential question: Are humans evolving, and how could we tell?
- Characteristics: a trait or something that describes an organism eg. A Bitson. moth may have a lighter or a darker exterior surface to the body
- Natural selection: a mechanism through which evolution may occur.
- Variation: differences in characteristics that occur within the same species eg. varying height in humans
- Heritable characteristics: Characteristics that may be passed on to the next generation.
Read the article on Industrial melanism provided.
Natural selection is the mechanism famously proposed by Charles Darwin to explain how evolution may occur.
Natural selection increases the frequency of characteristics that make individuals better adapted and decreases the frequency of other characteristics leading to changes within the species.
Natural selection: Watch and discuss this video. Summarise the meaning of three ecological concepts: descent with modification, common descent, and natural selection.
Natural selection can be broken down into the following principles:
- Variation. Natural selection can only occur if there is variation amongst members of the same species.
- Species tend to produce more offspring than the environment can support. Natural selection is only possible if there is a struggle for survival.
- Individuals that are better apapted tend to survive and produce more offspring while the less adapted tend to die or produce fewer offspring
- The characteristics that made them successful are passed on and become more common in the next generation – hence the change, or evolution.
Evolution by natural selection leads to gradual, progressive change. It is important to note that natural selection works at the level of the population, not the individual.
ie. It is not that one giraffe’s neck becomes longer. It is that in the population of giraffes, the frequency of giraffe’s with longer necks, becomes greater over time.
Activity: review this powerpoint on evolution.
1) Antibiotic resistance in bacteria is an example of evolution in response to environmental change. Using another example, explain how an environmental change can lead to evolution. (8)
A bacterial population with no resistance to an antibiotic may develop into a bacterial population with some resistance to an antibiotic. Which event could lead to this?
A. Antibiotic resistance was inherited from an ancestral population.
B. An antibiotic resistance plasmid is received from a bacterium in another population.
C. The enzyme needed for antibiotic resistance is received from a bacterium in another population.
D. The bacterial population mutated in response to antibiotics in the environment.
What is a direct consequence of the overproduction of offspring?
A. Individuals become more adapted to the environment.
B. They will be subject to intraspecific competition.
C. They will diverge to produce different species.
D. They will suffer mutations.
1. natural selection (in correct context);
better-adapted individuals survive/more likely to survive;
more reproduction/genes passed on by better adapted individuals;
name of species; (accept even if remainder of answer is invalid)
description of original/decreasing phenotype;
type of environmental change that led to evolution;
consequence of environmental change
description of new/increasing phenotype;
genetic basis of phenotypes;
reason for new phenotype being better adapted;
detail of reason for adaptedness of new phenotype;
The following has been provided as an example answer.
bird that lays its eggs in spring;
global warming/climate change;
more caterpillars (on trees) in early spring;
laying eggs earlier in spring;
time of egg laying is (partly) genetically controlled;
eggs laid early hatch at start of period of greatest food abundance;
more young can be fed/young grow faster/fewer deaths;
LESSON TWO: INVESTIGATING EVOLUTION IN LIZARDS
Artificial versus natural selection
Artificial selection is based on the choices of humans in breeding food crops or domestic animals
Conditions for artificial selection:
- Variation exists in the domestic population
- Some traits are desirable for the breeder, some traits are undesirable for the breeder
- Organisms with the desirable traits are chosen to breed with each other. Organisms without the desirable traits are not chosen to breed with each other.
- The offspring of the breeding pair are screened for desirable traits. The process repeats itself.
Some examples of Artificial selection:
Task: DIstinguish between natural and artificial selection
Virtual online Lab: Follow this online lab following a field trip to the Caribbean analysing species of lizards for the purposes of classification and the enhanced understanding of their evolution.
Task Get as far as you can and then complete a connect, extend, challenge exercise.
5.3 Classification of Biology:
- EQ5.3a Why should classification systems in science be standard throughout the world?
- Classification: Putting organisms into groups
- Taxa, Taxanomic groups: the groups that biologists use to classify organisms
- Hierarchy of taxa: the order of groups from most inclusive to least inclusive: Domain, Kingdom, Phyla, Class, Order, Family, Genus, Species.
- Taxonomy: the science of classifying organisms
- Natural classification: When classification is based on common ancestry
- Artifical classification: When classification is based purely on arbitrary groups (eg. for identifying venemous snakes).
Introduction: Activity: Classification systems involve organising species into hierachical groups. You will do an exercise based on school classification systems, to understand what it meant by more inclusive and less inclusive groups:
- Make a list of around 5 groups that your school has placed you in, for the purposes of organising your education. Classify yourself according to each level of organisation eg. Grade level – 11.
- Rank them in order from the one that includes the most students, to the one that contains the least
- Make a rule that explains the relationship between your classification any one group and the group above it.
- Make a rule that explains the relationship between your classification any one group and the group below it.
- Share with the class.
The basic principles of the modern system of classification are:
-The binomial system of nomenclature, which provides two names for every known species. They are the Genus, and species name eg. Homo sapiens.This system is universally used by scientists from around the world
- It is universal and can be used by all scientists.
- Latin is a dead language, and will not change. It is neutral (noone speaks it)
- The genus name is a classification group (and gives you information about the animals).
Discussion Task: Choose 1 or 2.
Q1. Did western scientists imposed the modern classification species system on the world?
Q2. Carolus Linnaeus also classified humans into 4 groups.
By 21st century standards, his descriptions can be seen as racis. How does the social context of scientific work affect the methods and findings of research?
Carolus Linnaeus, a Swedish Naturalist, was the proponent of the Binomial system of nomenclature. The system proposes:
- Two names (hence bi-nomial), for each species. Genus and species eg. Homo sapiens Homo – Genus, and sapiens – species.
- The binomial system of names is universal amongst biologists and has been agreed and developed at a number of congresses.
Note: Writing the Binomial system name:
Capitol letter for Genus, lower case letter for species.Use italics if typed, underline if hand written.There exists a hierarchy of taxonomic groups, which is used to classify living organisms.You can see the taxonomic hierarchy for a human and an ostrich below.
Did King Philip Come Over For Good Soup (Mmemonic for the above).
The domains – a new taxonomic group
Traditionally, all bacteria were placed one kingdom – Prokaryotes. It has since been realised that the diversity of bacteria is too high to realistically place them in one category. There is a group of ancient bacteria called Archaens, which are very different to other bacteria and probably were among the first living organisms on Earth. They are now considered to be a separate domain.
There are two other domains:
- Eukaryotes: Containing Fungi, Protista (single-celled organisms), Plants, and Animals
- Prokaryotes: Containing ‘true bacteria’ such as E. Coli.
Archaens are often found living in extreme environments, for example this hot springs in Yellowstone national park, USA. They also include methagens (bacteria which produce methane gas as part of their metabolism), this means they are found in the intestines of cows (and humans), and in the guts of termites, and are responsible for the methane emissions of wetlands.
Natural versus artificial classification.
A natural classification system, the genus and higher taxa consist of all the species that have evolved from one common ancestral species. In other words, evolutionary relationships is the basis for that classification.
Which penguins are more closely related by a more recent common ancestor?
In an artificial classification system, species are placed into groups based on arbitray classifications (subjective, and not due to evolutionary relationships).
Q) How could artificial classification systems be useful?
image credits: animal control
Need more help? REVISION Powerpoint on Topic 5.
Questions on slides 16-20
Lesson two: Recognising plants!
Big questions: How do we quickly classify plants and animals into classification groups into phyla, based on a casual observation?
- Phyla: a taxonomic group, containing more than one class eg. Bryophyta or mosses
- Dichotomous key: a chart for identifying species, based on the principle of splitting the species into two using a question which has two answers.
- Natural classification: classification system based on the closely related groups evolving from a common ancestor.
- Artificial classification: based on some arbitrary characteristic, not related to their evolution eg. colour
Classification systems: Natural versus Artificial
Task: Classify the following species into groups, using these criteria:
- dangerous and non-dangerous
- tree-dwelling and surface-dwelling
- Tool-using and non-tool using
Orang-utan, Chimpanzee, Gorilla, Human,, Bonobo Monkey,
Share with the class: Are these systems of classification useful in any context?
Without using knowledge of evolution, we are likely to come up with an artificial classification system – that is, based on arbitrary criteria. This may be convenient for us in some circumstances (eg. dangerous or not for jungle tourism), but has less biological value.
Advantages of natural classification:
- Identification is easier. Uncertainties about identification can be tackled with hierarchy of taxa (eg. I don’t know what Genus this monkey is, but I am sure it is in the order primate, and this gives me a place to start)
2. Because the members of a group have evolved from a common ancestor, they are likely to have shared characteristics. This allows prediction of the characteristics of species within a group.
Natural classification of the above groups
Recognising the phyla plants rapidly
The recognisable features of a phyla of plants or animals, are the characteristics that are easy to see and will help you to quickly understand which phyla a specimen belongs too.
Cycads are ancient plants, and are thought to have been eaten by the dinosaurs. Some living specimens also live along time, even up to 1,000 years. Which phyla of plants do you think they belong too? Review the recognisable features of the phyla of plants in the powerpoint above (slides 24-32)
Game: Guess the phyla of the plants from the photos
Fig 2. Giant Australian worm
The Giant Australian worm grows over a metre long. What phyla of invertebrate do you think it belongs to?
The phyla of invertebrates should also be reviewed (33-42)
Big questions: Is classification by common ancestors a better way of classifying species? How reliable are cladograms?
Lesson objectives: Understand how to draw and interpret a simple cladogram
- Clade: A group of organisms that have a common ancestor
- Cladograms: A diagram showing clades and their divergence from a common ancestor
- Divergence: When one species becomes two or more species by radiative evolution
Cladistics is the classification of organisms based on clades. A clade is a group of organisms that have evolved from a common ancestor.
Q) How do they know that the organisms in a clade have a common ancestor?
A) they know because the organisms share base sequences of genes, or the amino acid sequences of a protein.
Remember translation? The sequence of bases
on a section of DNA ultimately determines the
sequence of amino acids that will be made
from the gene see diagram —————)
Fun fact: Humans share 98.8% of the DNA sequences of a chimpanzee. OK, heard that before?How about this, we share 90% of the DNA sequences of a cat, and 50% of the DNA of a banana! With each other? 99.5%
A cladogram is a tree diagram showing the most probable sequence of divergence in clades.
The cladogram shows the divergence of groups A, B, C. These two formats of cladograms are both acceptable. The points where they diverge, are called nodes. Each node represents a hypothetical common ancestor.
OK, so why most probable? They are not always certain, there may be more than one possible interpretation of the data depending on which genes are used in the study. So, divergence? This means when the two groups of organisms stopped being the same, and started to have different characteristics (this idea links with speciation, as discussed previously).
Look at this example of a cladogram.
Explanation of cladogram: Using physiological features as a basis for this cladogram, how do they know the probable sequence of evolution? They use the fossil record. In the figure above, because the characteristic ‘having jaws’ is the oldest characteristic to appear in the fossil record, we know animals evolved them before lungs. In the table, the species are organised in order of how many of these extra features that they have. In this way we can track when species diverged eg. Sharks diverged before the evolution of lungs.
Q) How is this different to other forms of classification?
A) Traditional classification depends on physiology (the way that the body is designed and how it functions), and morphology (the shape of the body parts). Sometimes there is a discrepancy between traditional classification, and the newer classification of organisms by cladistics.
OOPS- this has led to massive reclassifications of plants!
Nature of science: Do you think it is advisable to re-classify organisms based on cladistics??
Analagous and homologous traits
Homolous traits eg. dolfins flipper and mammalian arm, have similar physiology because of a common ancestor.
Analogous traits are similar because of convergent evolution, they evolved separately to become similar eg. insects wings and bats wings.
Q.) Are organisms that share homologous structures more likely to be in the same clade, or organisms that share analogous structures?
A). Organisms that share homologous structures, because the clade shows a group of organisms with a similar evolutionary history.
Lesson two: Exploring Cladistics at a deeper level
Objectives: judge the implications for human evolution of cladograms involving primates AND understand how one cladogram may not be enough AND appreciate that cladistics have caused the re-classification of the figwort family.
- Figwort family (Scrophularaciae): a family of angiosperms that has had to be restructured completely based on the findings of cladistics
- Primates: a family of mammals that includes monkeys, apes, and humans.
- Mutation: a change in DNA
Introduction: read pages 275 classification of the figwort family, and primate cladograms 272
Activity: Video summary of cladistics:
Watch the video and try to answer the questions in this document:
Web activity: Re-visit some of the principles from last lesson by trying this user friendly web exploration of cladistics:
Lesson three: Making dichotomous keys
Objectives: Learn how to make a dichotomous key. Also learn how to use dichotomous keys to identify specimens.
- Dichotomous key: A numbered series of pairs of descriptions, which can be followed to identify a specimen.
Introduction: Read page 265 Dichotomous keys and the dugong. Be prepared to summarise the key features of a dichotomous key.
Activity: The lesson will follow slides 41-58 in the classification powerpoint above.
First you will need to play a game with the phyla you have been learning…
The you will be asked to create keys to help your friends identify the phyla, for example sharks.